Button Gwinnett: The Ghost of the Declaration
Uncovering the life and legacy of a lesser-known "Founding Father"
In the pantheon of American Revolutionaries, names like Jefferson, Adams, and Franklin echo with the weight of bronze and marble. But among the fifty-six signatures that birthed a nation, one name remains an enigma—a man who was neither a philosopher nor a general...
Original Engraving of the Declaration of Independence (1823) U.S. National Archives
... but a man of modest beginnings whose signature achieved lasting fame.
"This England" (Fairford, Gloucestershire) (1952) by John Taylor Arms National Gallery of Art, Washington DC
The man from nowhere
Button Gwinnett was born in Gloucestershire, England, the son of a Welsh vicar. He was a man of modest means and even more modest success. After a string of failed business ventures in England, he arrived in Savannah, Georgia, in 1765.
Map of British Colonies in the year 1765 (1765) U.S. National Archives
He tried his hand as a merchant. He failed. He bought a plantation on St. Catherine’s Island. Like many of his peers in the Georgia delegation, Gwinnett’s aspirations were tied to the plantation economy and the system of enslavement that powered it. Later on, he fell into debt.
The Philadelphia "plus one"
When the Second Continental Congress convened in 1776, Georgia was the most reluctant colony. Button Gwinnett was sent as one of its three delegates. In the sweltering heat of the Pennsylvania State House, Gwinnett sat amongst intellectual heavyweights that were changing the world.
Original Engraving of the Declaration of Independence (1823) U.S. National Archives
On August 2, 1776, he leaned over the parchment and etched his name. He didn't offer a soaring oratorical performance or a grand vision for democracy.
He simply signed "Button Gwinnett" and, shortly thereafter, headed back to Georgia to settle old scores.
The fatal grudge
Gwinnett was often more preoccupied with local political rivalries, such as the one with Lachlan McIntosh, a commander of the Georgia Continental Battalion. Their feud was a toxic blend of political ambition and personal vanity.
Pair of Miquelet Flintlock Pistols (dated 1757) by Francisco Pintan The Metropolitan Museum of Art
In May 1777, after Gwinnett failed in a military expedition to Florida (yet another failure), McIntosh called him a "scoundrel" in public. In the 18th century, these were fighting words.
"I shall expect you to meet me tomorrow morning... with a pair of pistols." — Button Gwinnett
Spo Duel Inc Fencing LIFE Photo Collection
On May 16, at a distance of only twelve paces, the two men fired simultaneously. Both were struck in the thigh. McIntosh survived; Gwinnett did not. He died three days later of gangrene, having been a "Founding Father" for less than a year.
The most expensive ink in history
The irony of Gwinnett’s life is his afterlife. Because he died so young and spent his life avoiding the "burden" of writing letters, his signature is one of the rarest artifacts in the world.
The Collector's Holy Grail: There are only 51 known examples of his signature in existence.
Value
While signatures of more famous figures like Washington are more widely documented, Gwinnett’s remains the rarest and most elusive for collectors. In 2010, a single document bearing his name sold for over $700,000.
Button Gwinnett (1735–1777) The White House
Button Gwinnett didn't win the war, and he didn't write the laws. His contribution, though brief, was immortalized on one of history’s most significant documents.
Today, he is remembered not for his deeds, but for his scarcity— a figure defined more by his struggles than his successes, became a legend nonetheless.
You are all set!
Your first Culture Weekly will arrive this week.
