Abdülmecid Efendi Beyond Vision

The results of the scientific analysis and conservation of Abdülmecid Efendi’s paintings from the Sakıp Sabancı Museum Collection

Abdülmecid Efendi Beyond Vision  project aimed to take a closer look at Abdülmecid Efendi’s art, revealing his painting process and discovering details beneath the visible surface of the works.

The Process of Scientific Analysis and Conservation

Composite of Mosque Entrance and its X-ray image Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Along with the types of pigments Abdülmecid Efendi used, the research unveiled his painting techniques and preparatory work underneath the surface of the painting.

Galleon in the Mist (1895-1896) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Galleon in the Mist

Abdülmecid Efendi did not receive an academic education in art, however he grew up within the flourishing artistic atmosphere at court during the reign of Sultan Abdülaziz (r. 1861-1876).  He painted Galleon in the Mist when he was twenty-seven years old.

The dominant element in the misty seascape is the silhouette of a galleon. The galleon, with its flag waving in the wind, looms over a pinnace with clearly visible oars.

In addition to rowers, there are also several passengers and various stacked goods in the smaller vessel. The artist depicts the sun shining through the fog, with rays of white light reflected on the bright blue waters of the sea.

The background of the seascape, painted in pale pinks and lilacs, gives the painting a bleak, tenebrous air. The lower right-hand corner of the canvas bears the artist’s signature and the date AH 1313.

X-ray image of Galleon in the Mist (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

X-ray images showed that the painting was in good condition, with almost no paint losses. The details of the weave of the canvas were clearly discernible. Studies revealed that the ground and paint layers predominantly contain lead white pigments.

Paint samples taken from Galleon in the Mist (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Pigment analyses uncovered that the ground and paint layers contained lead white. Samples taken from the sky and the sea revealed the use of Prussian blue. Vermilion was found in the samples taken from the lower corner of the signature and the cap of one of the rowers.

Young Girl (1906) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Young Girl

This portrait of a Young Girl , a pastel on paper work by Abdülmecid Efendi dated to 1906, is a painting that the prince made as a copyist. The original painting in this case is the Portrait of Beatrice Cenci , which is currently in the collection of the Palazzo Barberini in Rome.

The original portrait depicts a delicate young lady, whereas Abdülmecid Efendi’s painting shows a more stout, childlike figure, with a rounder face. The dramatic treatment of light in the original painting has been further accentuated in this work thanks to the use of pastels.

Images of the paper fibres under optical microscope , 2021, From the collection of: Sakıp Sabancı Museum
Show less Read more

The artist made this portrait of a Young Girl with pastels on fairly thick paper. The organic structure analysis of the paper revealed that it contains animal wool and silk fibres in addition to vegetal cellulose. Even though the paper is a brownish colour, which resembles lignin-containing pulp, no evidence has been discovered to support this claim.

Young Girl (1906) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Young Girl

The Sakıp Sabancı Museum Painting Collection houses two Young Girl portraits, both in identical frames. Abdülmecid Efendi painted this work from the self-portrait of Élisabeth Louise Vigée Le Brun (1755-1842).

In the original painting, Vigée Le Brun depicts herself with a grey and white scarf with gold embroidery tied twice around her neck and wrapped around her head.

The red sash around the waistline of her dress is also partially visible. Abdülmecid Efendi copied this portrait which he possibly saw in the newspapers, art publications, or postcards in his library.

Mosque Entrance (1920) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Mosque Entrance

Abdülmecid Efendi depicted historical scenes, animal figures, landscapes, still lifes, and especially portraits; however, he rarely focused on architecture or architectural details. In this regard, Mosque Entrance , in the Sakıp Sabancı Museum Collection, is a rare example.

The painting features an inner courtyard clad in marble tiles, with two sea-green columns with spoliated Corinthian capitals and two pointed horseshoe arches; one narrow, the other wide. 

The wide architectural element above the columns and the wall behind it are decorated in geometrically patterned, multicoloured panels. 

Beneath the wider arch, we can see a half-open wooden door decorated in the kündekâri style, with interlocking geometric elements, inlaid with mother-of-pearl and ivory. The arcade that is just visible through this door evokes aspects of early Islamic architecture.

Above the door is the Arabic inscription, written in jeli thuluth calligraphy, reading “O Great God, who opens all doors, please open for us the door to good fortune.”

The lower right corner bears the Arabic script “Abdülmecid bin Abdülaziz Han” as well as the dates 1920 (Gregorian), 1339 (Hijri) and 1337 (Rumi).

X-ray image of "Mosque Entrance". The male figure and carpet have been digitally accentuated. (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

X-rays unveiled that Abdülmecid Efendi revised Mosque Entrance shortly after painting it. He had begun work on a male figure, wearing a turban and caftan, standing on a carpet in front of the mosque entrance. Unsatisfied with the result, he later painted over this figure.

Paint samples taken from Mosque Entrance (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Samples taken from different points of the painting contained the following pigments: lead white, zinc white, vermilion, cadmium red, burnt sienna, ultramarine blue, cobalt blue, Prussian blue, phthalocyanine blue, chrome oxide green, and emerald green.

Hanzade Sultan (1936) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

Portrait of Hanzade Sultan

Hanzade Sultan is one of many portraits Abdülmecid Efendi painted of members of his family. He painted his granddaughter in Nice in 1936, when he was sixty-eight and she was thirteen years old.

The young Hanzade poses for her grandfather with her hands folded in her lap, seated in a chair placed in front of a saffron-coloured drape. 

Her blue kimono with embroidered flowers on the lapels and sleeves could be an indication that the Japonisme movement, which had a great influence on European fashion during the 1930s, was also in favour among members of the Ottoman dynasty.

X-ray image of the Portrait of Hanzade Sultan (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

X-ray images revealed that the canvas was lined over the secondary canvas to consolidate the painting, which had sustained damage, especially on the right-hand side. The damaged areas appear as dark lacunae, indicating the paint losses and cracks on the canvas.

Paint samples taken from the Portrait of Hanzade Sultan (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

The pigment analyses showed that two different blue paints were used for Hanzade Sultan’s kimono. These are made out of ultramarine and cerulean blue pigments. 

He used a combination of cadmium red, red lead and burnt sienna pigments to obtain the colour red.

He used two layers for the ground layer of the painting, the first of which is a thick layer containing lead white, and the second is a thinner layer containing zinc white. It is likely that the first layer was pre-applied, and that the second layer was painted by the artist.

The Russo-Turkish War (Undated) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

The Russo-Turkish War

The Russo-Turkish War is attributed to Abdülmecid Efendi, though it is not signed. Here, the prince has painted a war scene similar to the military victories depicted by his instructor Stanisław Chlebowski, commissioned by Sultan Abdülaziz.

The Ottoman soldiers on horseback are portrayed as the victors of the battle, with their swords in the air, firing their rifles. 

The Russian soldiers are easily recognisable in their navy blue trench coats, their uniform from the second half of the 19th century until the First World War. Their defeat is emphasised by the way in which they are scattered on the ground and by their smaller size.

If the painting depicts the Siege of Plevna, then the tower, partially visible in the background on the left-hand side, must be the Fortress of Plevna.

Composite of "The Russo-Turkish War" and its X-ray image. (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

X-ray images unveiled that Abdülmecid Efendi painted The Russo-Turkish War over another painting. The image might have been painted by copying another painting. When the X-ray image is rotated anticlockwise by 90 degrees, the figure on horseback becomes clearly visible.

The figure’s helmet, the horse’s head, bridle, reins and legs are bright and prominent. Since the figure was depicted with paints containing pigments with high absorption, the composition of the painting is plainly visible in the X-ray.

Paint samples taken from The Russo-Turkish War (2021) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

The analyses carried out on the paint layers indicate that the ground layer contains lead white pigments. 

The blue paints were found to contain ultramarine blue, carbon black and Prussian blue, whereas the reds include vermilion, red lead and burnt sienna pigments.

The Russo-Turkish War (Undated) by Halife Abdülmecid Efendi (1868-1944) Sakıp Sabancı Museum

The SEM-EDS results show that the colour green contains arsenic, which suggests that this paint may have been obtained from emerald green pigments.

The fact that Abdülmecid Efendi’s painting contains a large amount of zinc white shows that the artist worked on this painting until the 1920s, since toxic lead white was abandoned at this time in favor of zinc white. This knowledge provides insight into the date of the painting.

Results

During the Abdülmecid Efendi: Beyond Vision study, X-ray images of three of the four oil on canvas paintings revealed the areas where the works had been damaged and restored in the past. This process also uncovered that Abdülmecid Efendi had reused the canvas for The Russo-Turkish War, painting over a previous composition. Similarly, X-ray images of Mosque Entrance exposed a turbaned man standing on a carpet, later covered by the stone flooring of the courtyard, indicating that the artist changed the composition of the painting at some point. Although it is a rare example in terms of its subject matter, these X-ray images revealed that this work was similar to other figural depictions by Abdülmecid Efendi.

The pigment analysis results showed that Abdülmecid Efendi did not always use the same pigments in his paintings. For instance, it appears that to obtain the colour blue, he used Prussian blue, cerulean blue, and ultramarine blue pigments interchangeably. The reason for this might be that the six paintings that underwent analysis were painted at very different times. It also seems that the artist used quick and regular brushstrokes in some of his paintings and chose to apply thick, dense paint layers in others. While he could mix the binder and pigments on his palette quite thoroughly, obtaining a homogenous paint, he could also choose to combine them less rigorously, leaving discernible pigment particles in the paint.

Arsenic was detected in the green pigment used in Abdülmecid Efendi’s painting titled The Russo-Turkish War . The white pigment in the same painting was found to contain both lead white and zinc white. The fact that the work contains zinc white, a pigment which gained popularity from the 1920s onwards, suggests that the artist worked on this painting after this date.

Furthermore, FTIR data revealed that both of the Young Girl portraits, made with pastels, were made on the same type of paper. Both are examples of brown-tinted paper containing fibres from wool and silk rags. The pastels were applied directly onto the surface of the unsized paper, resulting in a velvety texture.

This examination of Abdülmecid Efendi’s six paintings in the Sakıp Sabancı Museum Collection provided insight into the artist’s techniques and use of materials. The pigment data pertaining to the oil on canvas paintings is presented below.

Pigment Analysis Data

Pigment Analysis Data , From the collection of: Sakıp Sabancı Museum
Show less Read more
Pigment Analysis Data , From the collection of: Sakıp Sabancı Museum
Show less Read more
A scene from the "Abdülmecid Efendi: Beyond Vision" studies , 2021, From the collection of: Sakıp Sabancı Museum
Show less Read more
Credits: All media
The story featured may in some cases have been created by an independent third party and may not always represent the views of the institutions, listed below, who have supplied the content.

Interested in Visual arts?

Get updates with your personalized Culture Weekly

You are all set!

Your first Culture Weekly will arrive this week.

Translate with Google
Google apps
Design a Mobile Site
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: