Yahoo
Small Italian cookie ice cream so good new fav flavor
Confetti/Cake Batter Flavor with Rainbow Sprinkles
Confetti/Cake Batter Flavor with Rainbow Sprinkles!
Cherry vanilla
Banana split Ice cream
View of shop from parking lot
Chocolate dip chocolate soft serve
Magic Fountain Ice Cream Ice Cream & Yogurt ·$

Website: magicfountainlongisland.com

Phone: (201) 823-1114

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Broadway and E 43rd St/W 43rd St

Open now

  • Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

907 Broadway Bayonne, NJ 07002 ·340.92 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 92 reviews
5 star
46 4 star
21 3 star
8 2 star
4 1 star
13
Kevin S. 05/22/26

Delicious homemade ice cream and ices. Green Apple totally amazing and delicious. So many flavors to choose from. Owner is real cook too.

More
Marisa M. 04/24/26

Continues to be amazing! My new fav is the vanilla soft serve with cherry dip. There is no over powering fake flavor of cherry, it is very subtle. It kinda tastes more like white chocolate. The...

More
Bibi B. 07/12/26

Ordered watermellom italian ice. It was smooth and very sweet. Expect long lines during sunmer and parking is limited. Service is quickly which is nice, they have someone on drivethru and another...

More
Dee T. 04/04/25

What can I say. The place has been around forever!! Their ice cream and shakes are awesome . It's cash only but that's ok. The spot is big with benches on the outside. You can walk up to the...

More
Michael M. 09/25/25

Ice cream store been in Bayonne as ONG as I can remember. Old school , walk up and order. Outdoor covered seating and parking lot . Soft and hard ice cream. Good service.

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: