Yahoo
Outside
Parking
Outside
Outside
Inside
Outside
Half the bagels are tiny, half are normal sized
Bagel Pantry Bagel Shop ·$

Website: bagelpantry.com

Phone: (732) 632-3100

Cross Streets: Between Pearl St and Main St

Open now

  • Sun 5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

545 Middlesex Ave Metuchen, NJ 08840 ·324.49 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 202 reviews
5 star
91 4 star
56 3 star
21 2 star
14 1 star
20
MJ H. 11/15/25

This place is a stone's throw from my in-laws, and we finally stopped in to grab some breakfast before heading home to Boston. There were lots of orders and it seemed as though we might need to...

More
Khanh N. 01/09/26

We love going here. Honestly, these are the hardest working people. We came in the morning of a snowstorm and they were ready to assist us. Super nice and friends. I always get the BEC and my bf...

More
Aimee C. 05/16/24

This is THE Central Jersey bagel spot! I remember the first time I was introduced to this place and was amazed that I was missing out onbsome place so close to home. They always have fresh...

More
Zo M. 12/10/23

Couldn't make it to NJ without a stop to The Bagel Pantry. The smell of hot, fresh and delicious bagels emits as you walk in the door. The service was courteous, and our wait was less than 2...

More
Dave P. 08/08/25

Fast service! Their bagels are very large and a bit chewy... just how I like them. I trued a specialty spread of cream cheese and bacon. Tasty and a good amount of bacon. Great to get still warm...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: