Yahoo
Underground Pizza
Pasta small dish with bread
Gluten Free Pizza
NY Pizza
Pizza By The Slice with Toppings
Cheese and Pepperoni Slices.
Grandma slices
Grandma pizza. Outstanding!
Beverage and pizzas
Underground Pizza Pizza ·$

For a slice of famed NYC pizza that won't let you down, head on over to Underground Pizza. Existing since 1976 right in the heart of the Financial District, this pizza haven offers a plethora of Italian delights. However, regulars recommend that you delve right into the pizza menu, for that's where the real treasure is. Find the Upside-down Sicilian Pizza melting away your weekday blues as you grab a bite during lunch, while the meatball, pepperoni or sausage options act as a pick-me-up on any day. Pay cash to avoid surcharge. 

Website: undergroundpizzanyny.com

Phone: (212) 425-4442

Cross Streets: Between Stone St and Beaver St/S William St

Closed now

  • Tue 10:00 AM - 8:30 PM

3 Hanover Sq New York, NY 10004 ·346.21 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 391 reviews
5 star
209 4 star
104 3 star
40 2 star
19 1 star
19
Marlena S. 10/15/26

shout out yelp for bringing me here - first slice post flight and i am HAPPY! super quick, convenient location, chill staff that recognize their regulars

More
Javette M. 08/22/26

Came here to support my local business and they didn't disappoint. Love the food and friendly staff made my stuff fresh and it was delicious. Ambiance is fine quiet and clean. Definitely will be...

More
Robert L. 03/25/26

Tucked beneath the constant motion of New York City, Underground Pizza feels like stepping into a slice of old-school authenticity that's becoming harder to find. The moment you walk in, it's...

More
Sahana R. 10/10/26

Loved the food and vibes of this place!! Staff was so friendly, (Ben was awesome). We tried their sweet chili chicken slice and it did not disappoint! Definitely will be back!

More
Scott K. 12/13/25

Five stars - Great We had such a great time eating here on our trip to NYC (8/29). The pizza was great. But the standout was the owner; he was incredibly friendly and funny. There was a lot of...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: