Yahoo
Pre-made side dishes & meals to-go
Grocery aisle
Need any honey for your honey?
Mushrooms with mango and onions.
Deli menu
Sandwich
Extensive selection of Chocolove
Parfait
THE AMISH MARKET
The Amish Market Grocery Store ·$$

Modern Tradition. We KNOW fine food!

Website: eastamish.com

Phone: (212) 370-1761

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E 45th St and 2nd Ave

Open now

  • Thu 7:00 AM - 9:30 PM

240 E 45th St New York, NY 10017 ·349.59 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
3.5 267 reviews
5 star
75 4 star
113 3 star
31 2 star
20 1 star
28
Pat T. 07/14/26

Amish Market catered my rooftop party for 35 people on Saturday night. Everything was absolutley perfect!! It started with a great experience with Janet figuring our what and how much to order....

More
Theodosios C. 05/22/26

MARKET: Ironic to find a Grocery Store named THE AMISH MARKET, a monicker associated with rustic simplicity, thriving in the heart of the big city. The name is primarily used as a branding tool to...

More
Natania C. 09/11/25

Cute market with tons of fresh fruit and vegetables, snacks, and mini lunch meals. I felt that the parfait I ordered here was just a bit watery. However, there was so much variety in lunch...

More
Xanthe S. 03/30/26

They have a most amazing thin crust pizza made to order, and, unlike most of what they sell, the price for a personal pie is cost effective. Not cheap, but not pricey either, running from...

More
David B. 09/09/25

The pre-made chicken, tuna, or egg salads at The Amish Market are routinely spoiled yet still sold. The expiry dates are meaningless. You may as well throw your money in the garbage if you...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: