Brennie's Pizza in Highland, NY – Reviews, Hours, and Contact Details

Good slice, nice people. Same family for over 3 decades.

Chicken Ceasar Salad drenched in dressing!

Calzone and grandmas pie. Burned and pricey

Once Pizza is burnt it taste like its burnt..

Brennie's Pizza Pizza

3.5 17 reviews on

Phone: (845) 691-7213

Cross Streets: Between Van Wagner Rd and Route 9W

83 Milton Ave Highland, NY 12528 ·388.77 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

3.5 17 reviews

5 star

9 4 star

1 3 star

0 2 star

0 1 star

Amy C. 09/25/26

We got the eggplant pizza and house salad.... 1000% recommend... oh how we have missed NY pizza ..Delicious!!

Gavin B. 04/30/26

First time at Brennie's! I don't know why I waited so long! The pizza is amazing! Service is quick and friendly!

JS W. 12/29/25

All I had was a plain slice. They were $3.50 and of average size. The ingredients matter, as the cheese, sauce and dough were each independently very good. A tad off the beaten path now that 9W...

Robert S. 02/09/25

Still the best. When I first moved to the Hudson Valley in '95, I would pass multiple pizza places, driving from Marlboro, to go to Brennie's. It's now 2025 and still find Brennie's to be the...

Jim T. 10/13/24

Ignore all reviews 1.5 years or older as they have new management/ owner. Good pizza and friendly staff. Meatball Sub is my go to fav.

Feedback