Yahoo
Half steak / half chicken finger
The Works - Treat yourself to a full course meal of a pizza that includes, Mozzarella Cheese, Margherita Pepperoni, fresh Mushrooms, with a
Mister Pizza Elmwood re-opened on Friday, May 29th, 2026 under new management after weeks of renovations.
50 Piece Bucket Regular Wings Half garlic, Parmesan  Half medium hot
Sheet pizza, cheese, and pepperoni
Specialty Slices available!
1/2 chiavetta and 1/2 BBQ wings
Cheese Burger
10 Piece Single Black-n-Blue Style Wings
Mister Pizza Pizza ·$

Mister Pizza Elmwood serves the best Pizza in Buffalo, NY. Whether your looking to order a classic pepperoni and cheese style pizza, or one of our many Specialty Pizzas, Mister Pizza Elmwood has you covered. We also offer Family & Party Paks which include both pizza and wing combinations. Our Buffalo, NY Pizzeria located at 1065 Elmwood Ave. in Buffalo, NY features an outside patio to enjoy our delicious food over-looking Elmwood Avenue. We can also accommodate delivery orders directly to your home or business 7 days a week.

Website: localedge.com

Phone: (716) 882-6500

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Elmwood Ave and Bird Ave

Interested in our services?

Open now

  • Thu 10:00 AM - 11:00 PM

1065 Elmwood Ave Buffalo, NY 14222 ·341.90 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
3.0 214 reviews
5 star
55 4 star
35 3 star
18 2 star
21 1 star
85
Rosa R. 10/11/26

One of the best pizzas I have in Buffalo I love the cheese and pepper And I also love the cheeseburger pizza

More
Danielle P. 10/02/25

We ordered burgers from Dirty Burger which is actually a ghost kitchen which you pick up from Mister Pizza, they don't have a yelp so I'm leaving my review here. We ordered Cheese Burgers and...

More
John C. 06/10/26

The place has new owners and all I can say is wow.. I ordered a steak pizza and I ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza. Both were fantastic.. I would say Mr Pizza Elmwood is back. It reminded me...

More
Joseph F. 06/18/26

Just ordered a medium cheese and pepperoni pizza from Mr. Pizza with a side of blue cheese. Served with a smile from the nice lady who handed it to me. I have not ordered a pizza from here in...

More
Marlo L. 06/02/26

I really like the pizza here tasty delicious the staff was great not rude nor disrespectful but great and helpful 10/10

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: