Only stayed one night but was a very charming place. Lots of thoughtful items available, water, coffee, wine glasses, umbrella. Nice breakfast in the morning in a charming room upstairs. Bed very comfortable. Although my son said the daybed was not comfortable. Very quiet despite facing the road. The reason for 4 instead of 5 stars was the mildew in the shower that looked like had not been cleaned in a while. Everything was very clean except for that.

This was our first trip to the Finger Lakes region and it was wonderful. There's so much to do in this area! I was very glad that we stayed at Rogue's Harbor; it was a convenient and comfortable choice, with so much character. It's not often we get to stay in an inn with a 200 year history and it has been lovingly preserved. What sets it apart is that while it has modern touches you'd expect, it hasn't been so extensively re-done that is has no character. (We stayed in such a place on a different trip in central PA--a historic house but our room was as anonymous as a Hilton). Rogue's Harbor has all the charm AND all the amenities. The included breakfast was delicious each of the three days of our stay, and staff are friendly. Our room faced the road and had a rather noisy air conditioner but we were so tired from hiking each day that we both fell instantly asleep each night in the very comfortable bed; if you are bothered by ambient noise then a room in the back may be better for you. I hope Rogue's Harbor has another 200+ years of welcoming future guests!

We had a wonderful time at Rogue’s Harbor! The room was cozy and the bed was super comfortable with the softest sheets! I have a lot of food restrictions, but the staff accommodated every need and I was able to enjoy a complete breakfast. It was such a treat!

The Rogues Harbor Inn has a rich and intriguing history, a friendly and professional staff, but it disappointed us in a few ways. The location at a busy intersection means road noise (if you book take a room facing the parking lot not the road). The room itself #2 was clean, large and well appointed but the road noise made it hard to sleep. The breakfast was over-hyped - very nice breakfast room but rather ordinary breakfast. The staff could not have been nicer, but we had an overall mediocre experience. The pub attached to the inn offers good food and friendly service. I would like to rank this place higher but I cannot go to 4-star.

You can always tell if an Inn Keeper is experienced and cares by their attention to detail and the comfort of their guests. The room has night stands on both sides of the bed with lights you can actually read by. There are black-out curtains and even a noise canceling device to mitigate the traffic noise which is inevitable with its crossroads location. The bathroom had a separate stand to set your toiletries. There was a drawer in the buffet in the hallway where you could get an item you had forgotten. Breakfast was delicious and nicely presented.Check-in is 4:30, but if you think you'll need an earlier time email the Inn Keeper 24 hours prior and she'll send you instructions for self check-in.A lovely stay.