Yahoo
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Plain Pizza
Jim & Nena's Pizzeria Pizza ·$$$

We are fourth generation pizza makers Who take pride in preparing our food the same way my grandparents did. We use locally sourced meats, quality cheeses, first cold pressed olive oil, and our freshly made sauce and dough In each order creating the tastes and flavors that have won York county over since 1958. We hope you enjoy our food as much of the we do!

Website: jimandnenaswy.com

Phone: (717) 792-6633

Interested in our services?

Open now

  • Sat 10:30 AM - 9:00 PM

2755 W Market St York, PA 17404 ·197.04 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Accessible

Reviews

yelp
4.5 18 reviews
5 star
12 4 star
3 3 star
2 2 star
0 1 star
1
T P. 09/28/26

I'm from out of town... Texas. Found this gem!! Pizza was perfect! Crust crunched, toppings were fresh and not over-stacked. Pretty perfect! The whole crew was super cool on top of it all.

More
Wanda M. 07/22/26

Very good pizza!! Ordered extra cheese and pepperoni and there was no shortage of each! Crust was just right and tasty too. Pleasant staff and manager/owner shared history of Jim & Nena's...

More
Jay S. 03/12/26

Best pizza around. And great hoagies too. Rolls brought in from Philly. Staff is nice and will remember you as a regular.

More
sco h. 06/23/26

This is a great restaurant however there is a young lady in here at the counter handling money credit cards touching equipment and handling peoples food at the same time she needs to be wearing...

More
Jason S. 12/11/24

I've only been to a couple of locations however this one is my fav of the two. Friendly helpful staff. Quality pie. I'm a fan of their crust. Also offers sandwich specials with fries and a drink....

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: