PLEASE heed our warning & do NOT stay here. By far, the most horrific experience I have ever had... dead bugs & dirt everywhere, holes in the wall, peeling paint, black mold on the ceiling in the bathroom, abandoned boarded-up building with bottles & debris directly outside window, no staff on premises, unsecured entry door with full access from the street to guest rooms. The breakfast location was changed to a site off premises without notification, hoodlums outside with loud talking/smoke permeating under the door & banging on all the doors at 11:30 at night. The owner is despicable; the rudest, most unprofessional individual I have ever encountered. He is clearly a slum lord who takes zero pride in his establishment and has no interest or concern for his guests safety or satisfaction. When I first attempted speaking with him, I was told he didn't need to hear all this; he subsequently hung up on me. My husband called back. Once again, he cut us short, disregarded our concerns and told us we should've dealt with the hoodlums ourselves... totally inappropriate and insulting. Please look at the pictures I've posted and STAY AWAY!!!!!!

Chef Mark was very personable. The breakfast Chef Mark served was beyond compare. The family style seating was great to get to know other guests and things to do in the area. They are currently under renovation but everything was clean and neat. I look forward to staying at 44 Spanish Inn again.

Chef Mark is a gem! His breakfast was fabulous: quality ingredients, amazing choices, attentive service. He also went out of his way to get me a parking pass prior to check-in. It's worth staying here just because of Chef Mark and his breakfast. The location of the Inn couldn't be better, right in the Historic District . The room was basic but had a mini-fridge. The facilities were generally clean but there were notable maintenance issues, such as broken bathroom blinds. All that being said, however, the property is in the process of being renovated and I am confident these issues will be resolved in the near future. Because of this, we will likely return.

Lovely location in downtown historic area. Wonderful breakfast. Manager was sweetest person. Will definitely use again.

I would not recommend staying at 44 Spanish Street Inn.This property markets itself as a luxury boutique inn, but in reality it falls well below the quality of even a standard Holiday Inn. Nearly every aspect of the stay felt like the cheapest product available.The towels were tiny, thin, and badly worn. The pillows were old and uncomfortable. The bathroom was extremely small, and several electrical outlets didn’t work. There was no complimentary bottled water anywhere on the property, which is surprising for a hotel charging premium rates. The TV doesn’t even include basic cable—only app-based streaming services that require your own logins.The biggest concern was security. Several doors either didn’t lock properly or didn’t inspire confidence that they were secure. That alone made us uncomfortable during our stay.Management was also disappointing. I specifically asked about a late checkout and was never informed there would be a $50 charge. Only afterward was I told there would be a fee. That kind of policy should be disclosed upfront, not after the fact.Based on our experience, the property appears poorly maintained and not accurately represented. Other recent guests have reported similar concerns about communication, access issues, construction, and the condition of the property, suggesting our experience was not an isolated incident.There are far better places to stay in St. Augustine for the same price. Save your money and book elsewhere.