Yahoo
Where the magic is made
Where the magic takes place
Rico's Pizzeria Pizza ·$

We are a small independent pizza shop in south Sarasota. We serve some of the BEST pizza in Florida and maybe the east coast. We do most everything in house from grating and blending our mozzarella. We make fresh bread for our subs and dinners every day. We mix and proof our own dough daily, cold proofing for 48 hours. We are NOT offered on any 3rd party delivery platforms as we want to serve you face to face and keep our quality controlled and high. This allows us to respond directly with you should the need arise. (And it will on occasion err BUT we will make it right ASAP) Come eat with us, a slice, a sub, a baked Italian favorite or maybe a slice of our homemade cheesecake. Mark, family & staff

Website: ricospizzagulfgate.com

Phone: (941) 922-9604

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Fri 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

6547 Gateway Ave Sarasota, FL 34231 ·764.14 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 216 reviews
5 star
124 4 star
28 3 star
8 2 star
19 1 star
37
Kelli K. 09/02/26

Great Pizza ! Warm and Cozy Dining In!! Great Prices Pizza by the slice and Ice Cold Dr Pepper.

More
Richard S. 12/28/25

Glad to be back for really good pizza. A few tables inside but it's really a no frills interior - the product is outstanding and it's primarily takeout. The staff works hard to accommodate...

More
Craig B. 10/29/26

The worst pizza ever. The crust was raw. The toppings, while flavorful, slid off the crust in a jumbled mess. Clearly, the Rico's team doesn't care about quality or customers. Rico's needs to...

More
Jojo C. 07/22/26

Best NY style pizza in town! Wow. Outstanding! Great slice specials too. Go Jayhawks!

More
Magdalena P. 04/17/26

I ordered Stromboli and a salad Salad was ok with only one slice of tomato The Stromboli was nothing but a dough with limited cheese and meets Will never order again

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: