Yahoo
Grab n go case
Butterscotch Pie
Butterscotch pie
Top: Apple Pie Bottom left: raspberry chocolate chip cheesecake Bottom right: combination. Peanut butter and brownie
Butterscotch pie
Mayday pie!  Yum!  Perfection!
Front counter and sandwich menu
Pie case
Front of building
Missy's Pie Bakery ·$$

Closed now

  • Sat 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

502 E High St Lexington, KY 40502 ·274.35 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 80 reviews
5 star
37 4 star
17 3 star
9 2 star
11 1 star
6
Jay Vera S. 06/02/25

Tasty pie and friendly staff! I tried butterscotch pie for the first time--good and not overly sweet. Very large though! The parking lot and building itself are a little awkward. There isn't much...

More
Theresa S. 05/05/24

Stopped in to check out this small pie shop in Kentucky and so glad we did ! They make homemade pies from scratch . The space is very compact , the counter is right in front of you filled with...

More
Katelyn C. 08/19/25

Did the butterscotch pie recipe change? I used to love this, it always tasted just like my grandma used to make; but the last two times that I have ordered-it's been a MISS! The custard is dry and...

More
Jessica L. 01/11/26

Amazing pie, friendly service! Could have gone daily on our trip to Lex! Too bad we didn't discover it till the 3rd to last day. We had apple, cherry, French Silk, Mayday, and Snickerdoodle....

More
Tammi W. 03/26/25

Stopped here in early morning on the way somewhere else. Open early and ready. We bought a whole pecan pie to take with us as I've heard having pie for breakfast is taboo lol. When we ate it, it...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: