Jimmy John's in Middleton, WI – Reviews, Hours, and Contact Details

Same Ham and Cheese - looks pretty pathetic.

A closed storefront on a Saturday afternoon! 4:25. No sign or explanation. Bad form.

Very sparse contents in my Ham and Cheese sandwich. I added mustard because they can't be bothered with it at the time of assembly.

My falling apart MEDITERRANEAN VEGGIE WRAP with no tomatoes.

#1 PEPE GIANT. Barely any lettuce. Lettuce is CHEAP. this may be the last time at this University Ave (Park) location.

Last time I visited this location it was closed. Today this sign offers a what's what. A mile away I see beggars not interested in a job.

Jimmy John's Sandwiches ·$

2.0 36 reviews on

Sandwiches made with hand-sliced meats, fresh veggies and bread that's never more than 4 hours old. Freaky Fast makes it Freaky Fresh. Order online for delivery or pick up.

Website: jimmyjohns.com

Phone: (608) 841-1100

Interested in our services?

Open now

Thu 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Fri 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sat 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sun 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Mon 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tue 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wed 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM

6921 University Ave Middleton, WI 53562 ·634.58 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

Accessible
Family friendly

Reviews

2.0 36 reviews

5 star

3 4 star

4 3 star

2 2 star

5 1 star

Dayna M. 09/14/24

What happened to this place?! I've been to this location twice in the past year and both times were shockingly bad. Several months ago I placed a pick up order for lunch on a weekday. The place...

Emily B. 02/19/26

New clean location has a drive thru, indoor seating, and a small parking lot. Our food was ready for our pick-up order, and everything was exactly as we ordered it. Tonight the bread on one of the...

Tara B. 01/17/26

Over the past 3 months we have been using this location for group sub orders. They have been awesome fulfilling orders and answering any questions. Huge improvement from last year when we did...

Thomas T. 03/14/25

Hard to complain, as I only needed a couple skinny/slim subs. It wasn't busy, so my sandwiches were done promptly. No complaints here, but nothing made this store stand out over others.

Dean Z. 09/28/25

Their hours say they're open until 10pm, but they most definitely are not open that late. I drove out of my way to get there before 10pm on Thursday night and they were very much closed.

Feedback