Yahoo
Should be like this
Oh this sugar cream pie is oooooh so good! It's seriously the next best thing to homemade. I'm so glad I found them!
Strawberry-rhubarb pie
Mehaffies Pies Bakery ·$

Home Made Pies & Cheesecakes Daily Since 1930. Hours: 8:00am to 6:00pm, Monday through Saturday. Closed Sundays. Fruit Pies - Berry Pies - Cream Pies - No Sugar Added Pies - Specialty Desserts - Seasonal Pies - Crunch Pies - Specialty Pies ''New York Style'' Cheesecake - Cheesecake Toppings

Website: mehaffiespies.com

Phone: (937) 253-1163

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Linden Ave and Pow/Mia Memorial Hwy

Opening soon · 8 AM

  • Sat 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

3013 Linden Ave Dayton, OH 45410 ·279.46 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 50 reviews
5 star
26 4 star
8 3 star
6 2 star
0 1 star
10
Stephene B. 06/20/26

Unexpectedly came across this dessert shop while in Dayton and it exceeded our expectations. The staff were friendly and the pies were DELICIOUS!

More
Doug R. 12/15/25

The chocolate pie rocks - something that is not widely available in SE Michigan. The pecan pie is also excellent. It tastes of roasted pecans and is appropriately sweet, not overly sweet. The...

More
Judy D. 06/29/26

Imagine my surprise to get an email saying my photo of a pitiful piece of awful pie was chosen for its quality. It was attached to my review of how BAD the pie was, and clearly shows how there was...

More
Ron H. 01/20/25

Watching a program on Boston foods, a section on Boston Cream pies led us back to Mehaffies Pies for Sunday desserts. Upon a change in ownership, we saw that the formula for the chocolate icing...

More
KD G. 06/29/25

Been in business for a super long time! Highly recommend their cheesecake with a side of cherries to top the cheesecake....oh so goooood! You can't go wrong with any of their freshly made pies!...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: