Yahoo
Building my home gym. Thank you play it again sports for having what I needed at a good price.
A small sample of what I have purchased at PIAS Carmel
Play It Again Sports Sporting Goods ·$$

At Play It Again Sports, we specialize in new and used equipment for fitness, baseball, softball, golf, and much more. When it comes to the equipment you need, new or used, we are your premier sporting goods store in Carmel, IN. We provide the best-fit sports gear that athletes need to perform at their best. It's our job and pride to ensure this equipment is right for you and your sport -- and most importantly, that it performs for you. Our lineup of sporting equipment includes plenty of top brand-name options. And if you have some used equipment that's in good condition and no longer need it, get in touch. We're proud to offer top dollar for your used equipment. Visit us today.

Website: playitagainsports.com

Phone: (317) 848-6044

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E 116th St and Keystone Way

Closed now

  • Fri 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM

2332 E 116th St Carmel, IN 46032 ·382.64 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
3.0 18 reviews
5 star
6 4 star
2 3 star
1 2 star
3 1 star
6
Chris W. 04/11/26

It's a shop on the smaller size but they take advantage of every inch of space. I've shopped here for everything from first bikes to soccer gear. The staff is knowledgeable and helpful but...

More
David V. 08/05/26

just had a bad experience .... so I had purchased two different pants for my son not sure which ones to get him because he was not with me neither pair fit him and apparently they have a seven...

More
Bob H. 03/15/26

I have gone to PIAS Carmel scores of times and never been disappointed. I bought used bicycles, a brand new recumbent bike, tons of baseball equipment including bats (new & used, gloves (new &...

More
Gary W. 01/01/26

Had a ton of used sporting equipment. Prices were very reasonable. Employees were very knowledgeable in what was by.

More
Paul C. 07/06/25

They are very helpful and knowledgeable. Usually they mark up their items very well. Make sure to bargain with them. There is always the right price an item. A lot of used selections but some are...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: