Yahoo
Cake as we ordered
Top is vanilla, bottom is chocolate
Amazing Cake - everyone raved about how amazing it looked and tasted!
Perfection!!
They nailed the galaxy icing with the addition of little pearls. Toppers added by me.
Classic Cakes Cake Shop ·$$

We offer many different flavors and fillings. We have a talented staff that will help you create your own custom designed cake.

Phone: (317) 844-6901

Open now

  • Wed 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

1752 E 116th St Carmel, IN 46032 ·383.11 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible

Reviews

yelp
4.0 107 reviews
5 star
69 4 star
7 3 star
6 2 star
7 1 star
18
Brooke H. 07/18/26

The COOLEST cakes in Indy! Classic cakes does a fantastic job. They aren't cheap but for the attention to detail needed to create something like this - it's art. I don't even want to cut it....

More
Jerry M. 07/13/26

I ordered a birthday cake with a horse head design on it for my wife's 70th birthday. They did a phenomenal job. Everybody at the party was talking about it and asked me where I got it. I told...

More
D. M. 06/03/26

The very best cakes! So happy to be able to purchase delicious Classic Cakes for many years and different occasions, especially birthdays.

More
Amy G. 03/23/26

So happy with the cake for my husband's 40th! Sent in a picture I found on Pinterest, and they matched it beautifully. Guests didn't even think it was a real cake!

More
Ro W. 10/03/24

I was having a bad day and decided a cupcake (or 3) would make me feel better. I was 100% right. I had the wedding cake, lemon/almond/orange, and pumpkin. My entire soul was happy. All three...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: