Yahoo
Awesome lemonade
Cheese steak with all the works and a fresh cut fry!
Picking up dinner
The world's best cookies
Grilled sandwich
Italian in front and chicken teriyaki in the back
I love the creativity... and the cheesesteak and fresh fries!
Chicken teriyaki!
Lunchtime for the win!!
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwiches ·$$

Website: penn-station.com

Phone: (317) 578-7366

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E 116th St and Junction Sta

Open now

  • Sat 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM

9785 E 116th St Fishers, IN 46037 ·376.62 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
3.0 46 reviews
5 star
10 4 star
10 3 star
7 2 star
7 1 star
12
Brock W. 08/18/26

First time at a Penn Station. Staff were super nice and I was impressed with how clean the restaurant and bathroom were. Food was also really good! My Chicken Parmesan sandwich was delicious....

More
Scott H. 02/28/26

Whoever does the hiring and training here does an excellent job. The staff is always incredibly friendly, helpful and fun to talk to. The food is terrific as well! (Downside: $18 for a sandwich,...

More
Missi R. 12/31/25

I was craving Penn Station today, so I made a slight detour on my way home to pick up lunch. Instead of my usual hot grilled sub, I tried a grilled sandwich. It was on regular sliced bread...

More
Christopher G. 12/29/25

I actually visited Philadelphia and went to two different restaurants for Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. Guess what!?! Penn Station in Fishers, IN is better than both of them. Service is good....

More
Sheree M. 08/17/24

Came here because I had a coupon 2 small subs, 2 small fries and 2 small drinks for 22 dollars. Had to wait a few minutes to for someone to take my order, even though nobody was in front of us,...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: