Yahoo
Oct 2 , 2022
It is packed
Old town signage
Packed bar
Tony for mayor of the Conch Republic!
The bartender who never greeted us
Screen shot of my decibel meter from approx. 50 from the speaker outside of the back door of Old Town Tavern on Saturday evening, 8/12/17
Pool table
Pool rules
Old Town Tavern Bar & Pub ·$

Old Town Tavern is housed in a historical site with the building being 100 years old. Coupled with friendly staff, a patio, pitchers of beer and pool tables, this place is one of the greatest dive bars in Indianapolis. In a comfortable environment, you can grab a beer, enjoy the big game on TV, play pool or chat with the barman.

Website: spar.com

Phone: (317) 846-5545

Cross Streets: Between Veterans Way and S Range Line Rd

Closed now

  • Sat 1:00 PM - 1:00 AM

29 W Main St Carmel, IN 46032 ·383.71 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
3.0 68 reviews
5 star
19 4 star
11 3 star
4 2 star
2 1 star
32
Garrett E. 08/28/26

I love this barrrr but definitely closing in a week.... Filling pitchers 2/3rds and got rid of golden tee. Bye bye for now ... the memories will never fade

More
Chris W. 06/08/25

If you can envision a townie bar that smells like smoke, has pool, and where everyone will know your name.....that's old town tavern in a nut shell.

More
Thomas C. 05/12/25

Why complain about a business' policy? I did a search for dive bars and found old town tavern. Friendly staff and customers. Yes this place allows smoking and they don't allow a person th wear...

More
Robert W. 03/02/25

Just a heads up about Old Town Tavern. In Carmel, IN. From another couples post. Just got police escorted out of Old Town Tavern for my husband having his hat backwards lol... Just a heads up I...

More
sean m. 11/26/25

I've never experienced such a terrible bar in my life the drinks are super weak really rude bar tender didn't even get to finish my credit on darts better spend you're money somewhere else

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: