Bagel Fair Incorporated, established in 1975, is a 2nd generation family owned business located in Nora Plaza Shopping Center (across from Target). Bagels are made fresh daily, from recipes made on the premises according to a family recipe over 100 years old. Come in and experience Indy’s only real New York bagels, but leave your credit cards at home! Our bagels are a bargain, and we only take cash.
Website: bagelfair.com
Phone: (317) 846-0950
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E 86th St and Evergreen Ave
Closed now
- Wed 7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
1300 E 86th St Indianapolis, IN 46240 ·382.78 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpAfter my early morning annual physical, I treated myself to a breakfast bagel sandwich from Bagel Fair. Someone got up early to make the bagels. The cases were filled with hundreds of freshly made...
MoreA lot of bagel options, friendly staff, lots of cream cheese flavors, pick up and go type of store, no where to sit / dine in. They have coffee/soda, sandwiches or bagels with spread. After...
Moreheard about this place from reddit and my coworker but it did not live up to the hype IMO. service was good and friendly, but the bagels itself were just so thick and hard, making it difficult to...
MoreI have been going here for years. Bagels are the same as NJ/NY style. It is a quick service place. No seats. Just walk in, tell them what you want, pay and leave. Great selection and the flavors...
MoreI've been wanting to check this place out for awhile now, and glad I finally did! It's a nice spot, but just know that it's not a place to come and relax as there are no tables or chairs, only...
More