Yahoo
Another good pie from Barnaby's!   #2 with a little extra sauce and a little well-done!
Sausage and mushroom pizza with copious amounts of fresh red pepper, and Parmesan
Atmosphere
Nasty hard bread sticks that are 1.75 EACH!!!! Canned cheese that tastes like plastic. Canned Parmesan cheese.
Barnaby's #2 with a little extra sauce and a little well-done, 8-22-2015
Another good pie from Barnaby's!
YES!- I like Barnaby's Pizza!!!
Barnaby's - Mishawaka Pizza ·$$

Website: mishawakabarnabys.com

Phone: (574) 256-0928

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Grape Rd and W Edison Rd

Closing soon · 9 PM

  • Tue 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

3724 Grape Rd Mishawaka, IN 46545 ·439.15 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
3.0 168 reviews
5 star
49 4 star
31 3 star
14 2 star
11 1 star
63
Tamie F. 07/24/26

Really interesting pizza. The crust is not really like crust in that it's not fluffy, but it is tasty. I did like the sauce. The veggie pizza was good, but I do wish that it had red peppers or...

More
Robert E. 10/29/26

Best pizza in town , and I've tried several different places in town, theirs has a special crust texture that's delicious.

More
Mike B. 10/31/25

We were trying to decide where to go for lunch and I said I feel like a really good pizza. My wife said, guess we're going to Barnaby's today. 128 miles later (about 70-80 miles less than going...

More
Mary Beth A. 07/27/26

Great meal for a reasonable price. You do have to figure out where to place your order but everyone was helpful. We should have ordered the 10 pizza for the two of us but will have leftovers for...

More
M H. 09/17/26

I ordered and prepaid for my pizza six hours in advance, with a scheduled pickup time of 7:15 p.m. I arrived at 7:10, but the cashier could not find my order--even though she was holding the...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: