Yahoo
Cloud 9 pie and ice cream dessert
S'mores Pie
Coconut pies
Caramel turtle pie
Chocolate chip pie
I-40
Christmas Cookies
I-40 pie
While these pies are adorable and made in shop, I was disappointed by the filling to crust ratio and there just wasn't enough flavor.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Desserts ·$$

Buttermilk Sky (n.) : An old Southern term describing a cloudy sky with the clabbered appearance of buttermilk. Buttermilk also happens to be a key ingredient in many Southern baked goods and is fundamental to the success of our signature desserts. At Buttermilk Sky, it is our mission to connect the past and present through the Southern tradition of scratch-made pie. Our desserts rival some of the best in the country and will quickly take your palate back to a time when fresh, hand made, baked goods were the standard, not the exception. We bake both full size and our 4" cutie pies fresh everyday!

Website: buttermilkskypie.com

Phone: (865) 330-3694

Closed now

  • Sun Closed

5400 Kingston Pike Knoxville, TN 37919 ·288.43 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible

Reviews

yelp
3.5 111 reviews
5 star
52 4 star
20 3 star
11 2 star
13 1 star
15
Amber L. 06/27/26

Best pies and thumbprint cookies around. I will go out of my way to come here and get sweet treats.

More
Sally H. 01/22/25

3.5 actually we got a variety of these pies for a thank you from management at work. There were all kinds of flavors, I 40,Named for Interstate 40, this twist on Pecan Pie connects us all. Topped...

More
Maureen N. 11/06/24

I got the smallest I-40 pie at the suggestion of some pie lovers. I have tried other pies before and did not find anything to write home about, but I was pleasantly surprised by the I-40. The pie...

More
Patricia L. 11/23/25

This was my first time at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and I will never go back! I bought 2 large pies and they gave me one wrong! I live in Newport which is almost an hour away, so I wasn't driving...

More
Becki M. 11/25/25

I love their pies. The servers are so nice and helpful. Coconut is my favorite. If you're close to knoxville go. Best of the best

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: