Yahoo
Lox bagel... for $5... insane WIN!!!!!
2 Everything Bagels Toasted
Interior
Inside counter
Counter area
Lox bagel sandwich
Chicago Dog
Breakfast bagel sandwich with egg and bacon
Store layout
Bagels Forever Bagel Shop ·$

Bagels, Deli-Sandwiches, Bagel-Boxes for Special events.

Website: bagelsforever.com

Phone: (608) 231-2427

Open now

  • Fri 6:30 AM - 8:00 PM

2947 University Ave Madison, WI 53705 ·631.20 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible

Reviews

yelp
4.5 169 reviews
5 star
108 4 star
36 3 star
15 2 star
5 1 star
5
Christina P. 01/24/25

While visiting from out of town, we stopped by Bagels Forever, and wow--what an incredible find! These bagels were absolutely perfect, with a beautifully crisp crust and a wonderfully chewy...

More
Maka C. 06/25/26

Bagels Forever is a Madison staple! Not to mention they have a wide selection of bagels and bagel sandwich options at a very reasonable price! This establishment is one of my favorite spots to...

More
Lisa L. 11/01/26

Honestly, this was terrible. Maybe because I'm an east coaster? Waited 40 minutes for a tiny, bland bagel sandwich. The egg was one of those microwaved egg patties. Zero flavor. My daughter got a...

More
Chris R. 03/07/26

The most stand out thing about Bagels Forever is the DRAMATICALLY lower than average prices. Breakfast sandwiches with egg and meat are under 4 dollars. Bundles of 2 dozen bakes and cream cheese...

More
Karolina J. 11/11/25

Super casual and quick place. Really great prices and they had a lot of available flavors.

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: