Yahoo
Inside
Vegetable Pizza ... unreal
Eggplant Parmesan Sub (massive, but you'll have to add your own seasonings like garlic, oregano, Parmesan)
Inside
Chicken Francese Pan pizza
Bbq pizzas
Pepperoni pizza
Plum Tomato Italian Restaurant ·$

Best deep dish pizza in town

Website: plumtomatopizza.com

Phone: (732) 499-9119

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of St Georges Ave and W Milton Ave

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Thu 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM

1008 St Georges Ave Rahway, NJ 07065 ·330.16 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 90 reviews
5 star
55 4 star
10 3 star
9 2 star
8 1 star
8
Becky F. 08/03/20

I'm a huge fan of Plum Tomato's pizza! Delicious, thick crust, and the perfect sauce/cheese/toppings ratio. Highly recommend their penna pasta pizza - THE BEST in the area. Their medium pizzas...

More
Lucas H. 07/09/26

i got a cheese slice there was zero flavor and i mean none. It almost tasted like a grilled cheese with how hard the bottom was. service was fine it's a pizza place. it was very clean as well...

More
Michele Elizabeth S. 05/07/25

Had an office event catered from here today. Flavor of the food was as expected but the pasta vodka was mushy as was the chicken parm and the garlic knots and the salad wasn't great nor was is...

More
George N. 05/04/26

Came here , bought a Sicilian slice .. just for them to say they don't take Apple Pay . Was pissed off because I didn't have physical card .. they don't take apple here don't waste your drive!!!!!!

More
phil c. 02/20/26

Just had a plain cheese pie. It had to be one of the worst pizzas I've had. There was absolutely no flavor whatsoever. It's almost like they left the salt out of the dough and the sauce had no...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: