Stopped in for a beer and met the bartender Rachel awesome personality! She’s been here for 20 years plus super nice personality! In town for the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting and just punching around on my E bike! Looks like a really good local crowd

I am very disappointed to write this review because I have always had a positive experience at Mister Toad until this Friday evening, 9/20/24. We were immediately met with the absolute rudest server any of us have ever encountered. This woman had a serious chip on her shoulder from the moment we sat down. She was derogatory, confrontational, careless, and utterly disrespectful. I do not understand how anyone has the gaul and the nerve to speak to a customer in this manner. This experience left a foul taste in my mouth and I seriously do not know if I will ever return to a place I once held in high regard. Shameful.

We read about this place and thought it looked so interesting and cool. We wanted to be sure to catch it when we visited the Old Market area. We went around 3:30 or 4 right after it opened. There was no one else in there except the bar tender who seemed disinterested in us. He wasn’t really paying attention and even gave me the wrong beer originally. He only started showing some “enthusiasm” when a group of other people (presumably locals who he knew) came in and then he suddenly perked up and asked if we were ok several times and all that. It was a really cool environment with a lot of beer choices but overall I wasn’t really impressed.

My favorite spot in the Old Market district. Relaxing and great service. Nice little patio area out front to people watch and chat. Gonna be there this weekend for the College World Series.

Love the atmosphere and vintage smell. Had a few drinks and the waitress was super nice and attentive. It’s the only bar in Omaha I’ve been to, so I have nothing to compare it to