Yahoo
Outside
Pizza making
Outdoor shot of Benny Vitale
Massive slices. Helpful staff (who consented to the photo).
Cool unique peels.
Benny Vitali's
The oven
Giant pizza ovens
Benny Vitali's Pizza ·$

Sometime a little soul food like a pizza and beer can do wonders for your mood and day. So where do you go to try that in Fredericksburg? Benny Vitali's is the answer. This pizzeria, with eight locations across the States has managed to create a massive following among patrons. All they offer on the menu is pizza and beer. Yes, that it and believe it or not, even though your options are limited, the place is flocked with hungry mouths every single day.

Website: bennysva.com

Phone: (540) 368-1690

Cross Streets: Between Hanover St and Charlotte St

Closed now

  • Wed 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

722 Caroline St Fredericksburg, VA 22401 ·110.73 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.5 520 reviews
5 star
326 4 star
104 3 star
43 2 star
21 1 star
26
Jared D. 10/24/26

Been here many times and have reviewed in the past, just can't say enough good things about Bennys. Great pizza, the best.

More
Carmen L. 02/01/26

I've been to Benny's many, many times the last few years and the place never disappoints. The shop always has cheese, pepperoni, and sausage on the menu, but they also have 2-3 monthly specials...

More
Maria F. 12/28/25

Recently, we got takeout from here for an event. Very easy to pick up! The boxes are insanely big, which highlights how big a slice will be! Tried pepperoni & cheese--loved the thin crust, but...

More
Abby M. 09/30/26

Great pizza for a great price--HUGE slices. A but salty. The service is standard and the ambiance perfectly sticky. Will visit again and again.

More
Chris A. 08/18/26

Fantastic! Closest thing to NY so far. Bought a whole pie and will be eating g it all week long. The 28 pie's only setback is how to transport it home. But the crisp on the crust is great and the...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: