Yahoo
Buttermilk Biscuits
Cookies & Cream Layer Cake made with homemade chocolate wafer cookies
Chocolate Raspberry Layer Cake
Banana bread
Counter
Vanilla Anginetti for Easter
Pumpkin Pie (slice)
Strawberry shortcake
Red Velvet Cupcake ($3)
Buttah Bakery ·$$

Website: buttah-bakery.shopsettings.com

Phone: (347) 833-7899

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Onderdonk Ave and Pauline Leblond Way

Closed now

  • Wed Closed

377 Onderdonk Ave Ridgewood, NY 11385 ·350.64 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
5.0 132 reviews
5 star
114 4 star
17 3 star
0 2 star
0 1 star
1
Aaron T. 08/19/26

Holy smokes, their Brooklyn Blackout Cake is impossibly good. They were friendly, the cake was ready right when they said it would be.. What's not to like? Will absolutely be ordering from then...

More
Yudelka S. 11/21/25

From first glance, Buttah Bakery didn't look like anything special -- you can't walk in, there's no display to browse, and you place your order right from the doorstep. But once we tasted the...

More
Kelly K. 11/09/25

This bakery is wonderful, hands down, on every metric possible. I'm the Mom in California who orders a new and different birthday cake every year for my Brooklyn daughter, and it's a huge hit...

More
Cerika B. 07/27/24

The cakes are good but lately I didn't enjoy it was much. Some cakes are a bit dry. But overall an awesome bakery.

More
C D. 11/18/23

Got delivery from Grubhub on a chilly pre-vacation Saturday and it was worth it. Pumpkin cupcake was great. Pumpkin pie was good. And the whipped cream packaging was adorable. Chocolate chip...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: