Yahoo
Chicken Alfredo pizza slice omg so freaking good had to go get a 2nd one!
Mild Wings
Half sausage and mushrooms
Fratello's Gourmet Pizza & Cafe Pizza ·$

If you're tired of overpaying for a lukewarm, subpar pizza, come by Fratello's Gourmet Pizza & Cafe, where we've perfected the thin-crust Sicilian slice. We make each pie by hand with our old-world family recipes. Your first bite won't be your last. Plus, we offer Italian catering so you and your guests can enjoy mouthwatering food. We can also whip up a variety of other tasty foods, including: - Pasta - Soups - Pizza - Salads - Sandwiches Whatever your favorite Italian dish may be, we can surely make it for you. We hope to see you here in Lagrangeville, NY soon - eat in or take out! Contact us today to learn more about our pizza restaurant.

Website: fratellosgourmetpizzas.com

Phone: (845) 471-5555

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Fri 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM

1097 RT-55 Lagrangeville, NY 12540 ·393.28 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
3.0 54 reviews
5 star
16 4 star
7 3 star
6 2 star
5 1 star
20
Jim C. 05/21/26

Food was ho hum. Service fast and friendly Clean, comfortable I would come back. I ordered by phone and took it with me.

More
Rebecca B. 08/01/26

Although he read the reviews, we really enjoyed going to Fratello's . We had their Square sliced pizza - we enjoyed the first slice so much that we got seconds. We enjoyed person making the pizzas...

More
Louise M. 10/09/24

Food is mediocre at best, staff and owner are rude. They don't care about quality of food or customers. There are many high quality pizza restaurants in this area, Fratellos is definitely not one...

More
Aj A. 04/16/25

The food is not consistent. Sometime great next time same dish is horrible and chicken was like rubber. I am not going back.

More
Jay B. 09/21/22

Food was horrible , the pizza was barely Cooked , one of the workers , Justin Soriano , was cursing out loud to my children , I was very unhappy about this , my poor children were being so upset...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: