Cretia Cakes Bake Shop in Indianapolis, IN – Reviews, Hours, and Contact Details

Southern custard pie topped with pecans.

Sweet Potato Pie is another Southern staple dessert. Loaded with sweet potatoes -not from a can- butter, sugar, and spices.

These buttery, crumbly treats melt in your mouth. Soft and showered in sugar, your taste buds will be delighted and crave more. Baked fresh

Bundled up and ready to go: Caramel Cakes!

Absolutely delicious yeast rolls! Not one was left!

Strawberry, lemon, chocolate, and confetti cupcake.

Cretia Cakes Bake Shop Cupcake Shop

5.0 12 reviews on

Specializing in: - Bakeries

Phone: (317) 929-1560

Open now

Fri 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Sun Closed
Mon Closed
Tue Closed
Wed Closed
Thu 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM

4640 N Keystone Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205 ·380.50 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

Accessible

Reviews

5.0 12 reviews

5 star

10 4 star

1 3 star

1 2 star

0 1 star

Khadijah B. 01/24/26

Everything was delicious! I really like the dew drops and the mexican wedding cookies. Her caramel cake is divine and the homemade rolls were so buttery and soft. everything was 10/10

Aye L. 12/22/24

I'd had the privilege of enjoying Cretia Cakes at Zoobilation and Museum by Moonlight and fell in love! Both times--if I remember correctly--I fell in love with the caramel cake. While I was...

mary 12/16/24

Best coconut cake ever. And they got it done for me in record time. My new go to bakery!!!!!

Danielle G. 04/05/20

The caramel cakes are the only thing getting me through this quarantine situation! I was able to order my cakes online, then pick them up curbside 2 days later. I love how accommodating Cretia...

Tiana W. 07/17/20

I've had two cakes made within a month by Cretia Cakes. Each time the cakes were exceptionally made but with terrible and untimely customer service. Hours of operation are posted on their website...

Feedback