For over 15 years, Gib's Bagels has been serving up authentic, delicious New York style bagels right here in northern Colorado. We've been voted “best bagel” in Fort Collins for so many years it’s hard to keep track! When creating the best bagel in Fort Collins, Colorado, the key is remembering that “the recipe is in the process, not just the ingredients,” says Mike Howland, owner of Gib’s Bagels. Our expertise in the preparation of authentic New York Style bagels is what makes a Gib’s bagel so delicious. Our bagels take 24 hours to prepare because of the several steps the dough must go through. If even one step is missed or fumbled, you will wind up with a bagel that can’t be served.
Phone: (970) 224-5946
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of S Shields St and Raintree Dr
Open now
- Thu 6:00 AM - 8:00 PM
2531 S Shields St Fort Collins, CO 80526 ·1384.12 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Wifi
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpYum! Staff is kind and the parmesan bagel is delicious. They have a lot of cream cheese flavors
MoreWe had a quick lunch here that was quite pleasant. They have green chile cream cheese, which I had on a toasted parm bagel. They also had a lot of soups- if I lived here I'd probably work my way...
MoreWhen I lived here many years ago this was the best bagel spot in town, but they've gone downhill dramatically. The bagels are small and dense, and the dough is under-salted. They skimp on butter...
MoreA friend that's lived in Fort Collins their entire life and grew up near Gib's took me to this place for the first time and I really enjoyed it. You can feel the deep community roots and the...
MoreThe staff is very rude and condescending, treats people of color and neurodivergent like we are aliens. A bunch of spoiled entitled college kids with no more abilities than to make bagels. Got...
More