Yahoo
Meat lover pizza
15
Happiness
Antipasto salad
House Salad
Meatball sub
Chicken, mushroom, artichoke hearts - Yum!
Garlic cheese sticks
Marguerite
Lucy's Pizzeria Pizza ·$$

The Best Dough & Sauce in the Business! Here at Lucy's our dough is prepped fresh daily from only the best ingredients. Our homemade Italian Marinara Sauce simmers on the stove for hours, infused with authentic Italian spices. Come in and taste our authentic new york style crust and sauce. If you enjoy thin-crust NY style pizza you will love our pizza. Always hand-made and hand-tossed! Visit one of our four locations in Ammon, Idaho Falls, Roberts, and Orem, UT!

Website: lucysnypizza.com

Phone: (208) 523-7777

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Fri 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM

2770 S 25th E Idaho Falls, ID 83404 ·1746.24 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 121 reviews
5 star
60 4 star
29 3 star
13 2 star
7 1 star
13
Gary B. 07/25/26

Food: I enjoy their food, I think they have the best pizza in the Idaho Falls area. Their pizzas are consistently the same which is important to me. I would say it's very close to a genuine New...

More
Hope D. 09/23/26

Lucy's Pizza in Idaho Falls was wonderful all the way around! We ordered a pepperoni pizza and cheese sticks, and everything came out hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. The turnaround time was...

More
Barbara S. 06/04/26

Lucy's Pizzeria in Roberts has never disappointed! Love the crust, the sauce, the choice of toppings. The calzones are amazing as well!

More
Rick G. 12/24/25

How do they only have 4 stars?? This place is amazing. Food has tons of flavor some unique combos that are very tasty. The staff could not have been better!!! They were fast and very friendly...

More
Hayley E. 06/21/25

We like the crunch of the wings but the buffalo sauce tasted store bought. Nothing special to the flavor. We rank pizza as number 3 to mackenzie river then papa tom's then this. We enjoyed the...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: