Yahoo
Fried Calamari (appetizer)
Pepperoni Pie
Zaltar The Fortune Teller
Half regular pizza half pepperoni
Meat Stromboli meat lovers celilian
The table at the end is where I was sitting, no one is sitting there when I was walking out. Reserved?
Chicken and Cheese Roll
Stromboli & restaurant quality margarita w/ salt
Cyclone, located across the street from the Surf City Pizzeria
Surf City Pizza ·$

Pizzeria italian resturant . Coffe dessert place and Ice cream shop

Website: surfcitypizzeriamenu.com

Phone: (718) 676-4460

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Surf Ave and W 10th St

Closed now

  • Thu 11:30 AM - 8:00 PM

837 Surf Ave Brooklyn, NY 11224 ·343.14 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 107 reviews
5 star
60 4 star
16 3 star
10 2 star
10 1 star
11
Mike S. 07/31/26

Staff was super friendly. We sat down right away and ordered two slices. One pepperoni and one cheese. Cut them bad boys in half and swapped them, because we like to do that. Each slice was...

More
The Rogue Restauranter T. 10/25/26

Came in cold and hungry, left warm, stuffed, and happy! Great food, great service, great staff!

More
Brad H. 11/01/26

The Pizza Is Awesome!! No doubt about it! I keep coming back because it's a family restaurant!! Always Extremely Professional And Very Helpful!! They CARE about everyone in the community!!!!...

More
Christina C. 07/31/26

Immaculate service, slices as big as your face and a great Brooklyn lager to add to your meal. I highly recommend eating here. The vibe inside is amazing as well.

More
Nataliya K. 07/21/25

We stopped by to get my niece some pizza , and it was really good . I feel like Surf city is under new management . Their menu changed The service was attentive , the atmosphere was friendly ....

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: