Hand-tossed NY-style slices & pies in Indianapolis. $10 Lunch. 1/2-price 12" Mondays. Open late. Counter service, dine-in, carryout, delivery.
Website: goodfellaspizzeria.com
Phone: (317) 744-0491
Cross Streets: Between E 62nd St/Winthrop Ave and Guilford Ave
Closed now
- Wed 11:00 AM - 12:00 AM
914 Broad Ripple Ave Indianapolis, IN 46220 ·382.09 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Accessible
- Wifi
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpQuick and easy for a slice. Typical wait for whole pizzas. Over all great small shop pizza vibe.
MoreOkay, don't get me wrong, the pizza is good, but I cannot believe I paid $37 for a 16 pizza?! Wth?? My wife ordered the Vinnie which is one of their garlic and ricotta specialty pies and then...
MoreFirst time here and the pizza was delicious, perfectly made. It is small in there as we ate inside. I do wish they had bigger plates for the huge slices because it was pretty messy to eat.
MoreBumping up my review for this Goodfellas Pizzeria because the 22-inch pizza is impressive. I've ordered the 22 twice now, and each time, I'm completely taken aback by how large it is. I felt like...
MoreForewarning this place only offers bar style seating so it wasn't ideal with children. The food was great and the staff is so dang nice it's enough to make me come back here!! Place was clean,...
More