Yahoo
Peanut Butter Pecan, Blood Orange Cream Pop, Kitchen Sink
Pistachio soft serve
strawberry, Cookies & Cream, Vegan Grasshopper
Pistachio soft serve
Banoffee Pie
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Ice Cream & Yogurt ·$$

Oddfellows – DUMBO offers unique flavors of ice cream that are sure to surprise your taste buds. While most flavors are truly ‘out of the box,’ you can also order classic delights like ‘Cookie and Cream’ and ‘Chocolate Chunk.’ Pair your ice cream with a delightful ice cream cake that will only keep you wanting more. Ice-creams are priced at pocket-friendly rates which is only a cherry on top of the cake.

Website: oddfellowsnyc.com

Phone: (718) 683-5755

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Water St and Dock St

Interested in our services?

Open now

  • Sat 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM

44 Water St Brooklyn, NY 11201 ·346.92 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
4.0 185 reviews
5 star
97 4 star
50 3 star
17 2 star
11 1 star
10
Stephanie Q. 10/30/26

Amazing local icecream shop! I believe this is actually their original location? Place is quite clean and spacious with a couple of seats inside The employees here were really nice very like hit...

More
Melanie Y. 09/11/26

Thick and creamy ice cream, what more do you need? Not a ton of flavor choices, but many ways you can ingest them (sandwich, float, and more). I've visited many times over the years and was sad to...

More
Suzy F. 09/09/26

Went for ice cream last week and it was very good! The shop is super cute and had very quirky and fun decor! The quality is great and had a very creamy and smooth texture. I'm a sucker for...

More
Melody C. 04/26/26

This location allows you to book it out for a private party! You're allowed to bring your own food and drinks, and their ice cream is unlimited. However, it only applies to the scoops, soft serve,...

More
Brandon Y. 08/14/25

When I heard about the Breast Milk Ice cream collab that they were having with Frida, I had to come by. I'm an open-minded guy so I'm totally into trying anything and most of us HAVE had breast...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: