Classic NY style pizza. By the slice counter service. Whole Pies. Knots. Calzones. Soda (fountain and bottle). Draft and Can beer, draft and bottle wine. Delivery. Famous "Spicy Pepperoni" Square!
Website: madeinnewyorkpizza.com
Phone: (646) 484-6200
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Amsterdam Ave and W 80th St
Closing soon · 11 PM
- Wed 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
421 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024 ·350.48 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Accessible
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpI'm so glad I decided to stop in after walking past this place several times while staying nearby. It turned out to be one of my favorite pizza spots :) One thing I really appreciated was the...
MoreGrabbed a few slices here one evening and they forgot our order so it took ages, but the pizza was decent. I recommend the mushroom and sausage slices. Margherita was eh. 3.5 stars.
MoreHeard a lot about Made in NY being some of the better slices the city has to offer and I was quite skeptical because there's sooooo many locations and it has these large stores with bright lights...
MoreThis place is really hit/miss, VERY inconsistent: -sometimes delicious, fresh pizza -sometimes dried out, old pizza -sometimes inedibly salty -sometimes so bland I have to add everything -most...
MoreTotally what we wanted in terms of New York pizza. Thin slices with good flavors without trying too hard.
More