Yahoo
0.5 of the inside
Inside
Tavern style pizza
Our pizza with a couple of slices missing! (ha ha)
Fronds of glory cocktail
Outside is super cute
Omnivore 12
Closeup of a slice of the Whipped Ricotta pizza
Cutting a slice of pizza
Deep dish Ricky :D
Windy City Pie Pizza ·$$

Windy City Pie at Elliott Avenue West, brings deep-dish Chicago pizza to the Seattle crowd. They have invented some new pizza craft or baking styles without deviating from the conventional ways of pizza-making. This Seattle based restaurant has utilized all the forms of catering services to its customers. Drop in to dine or carry out your food or even place an order with them. 

Website: windycitypie.com

Phone: (206) 486-4743

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Phinney Ave N and N 60th St

Closed now

  • Sun 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

5918 Phinney Ave N Seattle, WA 98103 ·2276.22 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Smoke-free

Reviews

yelp
4.0 669 reviews
5 star
404 4 star
112 3 star
63 2 star
47 1 star
45
Sarah E. 04/12/26

my husband and i both remarked we were regretful to have never tried this place before (we've lived in the area for years!!). it was SUPERB. yes it's on the high end price wise but you truly get...

More
Gina L. 01/06/26

Came with a group of 4 on a Sunday right after they opened (12pm) with no wait. Got the Sweet Pete, which took about ~25 min to prep. Waitress gave us a little tutorial on how to slice the pie,...

More
Gordon D. 11/23/25

Windy City Pie is pretty close to where we live so over the years we have been frequent customers. We have only got pizza to go so I can't speak to the service or the ambiance, only the pizza....

More
Arielle M. 11/20/25

TLDR: Takes about 30 min for a pizza once you order. Great for big groups since pizzas are large and filling. Went on a rainy night so it was pretty empty. Staff was nice and attentive. The...

More
Jessy P. 11/11/25

Overall, not a bad experience. Being from Chicago originally, I've been on a mission to find the closest pizza to back home that I can find - bring on the tavern! The decor is full on Chicago...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: