Yahoo
Inside is awesome. I see employees cleaning. Nice
Inside they also have gelato
Large ceaser - great home made dressings
Olive bread
Yes I took that bite outta that slice. I'm marking my pizza slice
The Popeye Pizza... straight  off the menu, no alterations... The Popeye
Menu 02-03-2025
Lost Pizza Company Pizza ·$$

Website: lostpizza.com

Phone: (850) 495-5900

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Thu 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

550 E Nine Mile Rd Pensacola, FL 32514 ·682.38 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
4.0 242 reviews
5 star
126 4 star
39 3 star
28 2 star
25 1 star
24
Miranda K. 05/06/26

This will be funny so keep reading 1. We called at around 3 pm the day before and needed 36 pizzas and enough salad for 130 people and they said yes with no hesitation! 2. The funny part -- those...

More
Stephanie F. 08/01/26

I had a very disappointing and concerning experience at Lost Pizza Co. on Nine Mile Road in Pensacola during Music Bingo Night on July 28, 2026. While dining with my children, I was injured by a...

More
Erin B. 07/20/26

Average experience now. When this place first opened up to about three years after it was great! The staff was friendly and enthusiastic and the food was really great. Now it seems like the staff...

More
Bonnie B. 02/06/25

Lost Pizza Company did us right on Muffuletta Monday! The olive bread is a MUST! There are lots of unique options on the menu but because I hadn't been before and we were trying to keep with...

More
Cynthia D. 08/08/25

My husband brought home a pizza from here today. It's a huge pizza & so delicious. It's the next best pizza we have eaten out in Pensacola. It's a New York Style Pizza. He ordered our favorite...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: