The Game Cave in Batavia, NY – Reviews, Hours, and Contact Details

Warhammer and 40k are our quickest growing new games! Stop by and learn to play or grab a starter set for you and a friend!

We have a large playspace, and can seat 40 comfortably for events.

POP! Figures for all the newest collections.

Stop by any time to play some games, or at the listed times for one of our organized play events!

We keep a strong inventory of all current edition D&D books, and restock often!

JP WAR has been selling hot lately, and we've got some!

Keychains from every anime you can think of!

The Game Cave Tabletop Games

3.5 3 reviews on

The Game Cave is the only place in town with paper MTG Tournaments and Singles. We sell restockable sealed product at or below MSRP, and keep a large single selection of Standard, Modern, and Legacy staples.

Website: gamecaveny.com

Phone: (585) 219-4615

Interested in our services?

Closed now

Thu 2:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Fri 2:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sat 12:00 PM - 6:00 PM
Sun 12:00 PM - 6:00 PM
Mon Closed
Tue Closed
Wed 2:00 PM - 10:00 PM

563 E Main St Batavia, NY 14020 ·351.99 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

Accessible

Reviews

3.5 3 reviews

5 star

2 4 star

0 3 star

0 2 star

0 1 star

Jeremy C. 05/10/19

This is Batavia's RPG, tabletop and Magic the Gathering (and more) one stop shop. I've only recently discovered this place located next to Dominos pizza (which is convenient to say the least if...

Christian M. 09/26/26

1st time at the store and definitely the last. I go to many stores and always avoid ones like these. They have everything for SCALP price , i mean market and its for a reason( no one buys it) ....

Travis B. 12/22/25

The owner is a reasonable person, and I enjoy doing business here. My son is really into Pokémon, and he has help us out immensely.

Feedback