Yahoo
Smoky Tobacco, Cherry Bourbon Rita served up (I preferred it this way)
Wolfie's fries
Cherry bourbon rita, barrel pick (Bulleit) old fashioned
The Broken Barrel - Carmel Bar & Pub ·$$
Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Sun Closed

1156 Keystone Way Carmel, IN 46032 ·382.70 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Smoke-free

Reviews

yelp
4.5 70 reviews
5 star
54 4 star
9 3 star
2 2 star
2 1 star
3
Nicole S. 10/08/26

This is not the place for wine people. I saw no wine on any menu at The Broken Barrel. But, for real, that's OK with me. And I say this as a hardcore wine person. I fully accept that this is a...

More
Beth B. 06/27/26

Another wonderful night at the Broken Barrel. This is one of Carmel's hidden gems. Attached to Wolfie's, but a 21 and over space only . The ambiance is a quiet, private, speakeasy like...

More
Diane C. 01/18/26

Just went for cocktails and they did not disappoint. Creative creations, attentively served.

More
Jessi G. 07/12/25

Had girls night on a Friday night. It was slower than normal but Peggy took excellent care of myself and two friends. She had an awesome attitude the second we walked into the door. She made us...

More
Mary H. 06/25/24

We loved it here. This was our first time and our server/bartender was so kind and helpful. The food came out quickly and the drinks came out in about 5-6 minutes as they are craft...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: