Yahoo
Maple cinnamon Oreo
Menu
Stale-ish Homemade Oreo
Bakery options
If consistent deliciousness was a person
Red Gate Bakery Restaurant

Greg Rales gleans inspiration from the baked goods of his childhood, reimagining them with unique and unexpected ingredients. Our pastries, which range from cookies to loaves to celebration cakes, are crafted with premium ingredients and ably walk the line between familiar and sophisticated. Red Gate’s signature creations include Salted Caramel Brownies (chocolate brownies with a thick ribbon of caramel), Brown Butter Blondies (extra buttery, toasted pecan-riddled blondies), Cannibal Cookies (caramelized sugar cookies packed with house-made oreos) White Chocolate Grapefruit Cookies (studded with zesty grapefruit and white chocolate chunks), and Midnight Banana Bread (black cocoa and bittersweet chocolate in warm banana bread), among others. For custom confectionary delight, Red Gate Bakery also offers a line of Celebration Cakes in four flavors: Yellow Birthday Cake with Chocolate Sour Cream Frosting (the perfect combination of sweet and tangy), Vanilla Bean Strawberry Dream (fluffy vanilla sponge complemented with tart pink frosting), Caramelized White Chocolate Stout (nutty caramelized white chocolate with a kick from dark, earthy stout) and the indulgent Toasted Coconut Banana Bacon (bacon fat-infused banana sponge topped with cream cheese frosting and adorned with bacon bits and coconut shavings).

Website: redgatebakery.com

Phone: (646) 870-5553

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E 1st St and 1st Ave

Closed now

  • Wed 11:00 AM - 6:00 PM

68 E 1st St New York, NY 10003 ·347.81 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.5 156 reviews
5 star
90 4 star
38 3 star
19 2 star
2 1 star
7
Mark S. 05/25/26

This small, assuming storefront is one of the best hidden gems and bakeries in the city. They have some of the best sweet pastries I've ever had! - First of all, their chocolate chip toffee cookie...

More
Simon W. 10/06/26

Small bakery with big dreams. This small shop had a big line outside on a Saturday before opening. For some reason that always draws me in,.... Haha. Anyway I did need a sweet for dessert and...

More
Laura O. 07/25/26

I've been following Red Gate Bakery for a while now, hoping to try one of their weekly rotating selection of cinnamon rolls. I went for the first time today, but since I was planning on walking...

More
Amanda C. 07/23/26

{Overall: 3; Food: 2.5} Ambiance: 3; Service: 4 I'm confused about the hype around Red Gate Bakery. The pastries were mediocre. *Cinnamon Bun: This was dry and stale. There are much better...

More
Megana V. 10/18/26

came here specifically for a short term speciality corn cake which they ran out of ripppp. got their famous banana bread and fruit bun. the banana bread was ok, tbh couldn't taste the banana, was...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: