Yahoo
NY by the slice get ya some trust me you'll want more
Cannolis!!
Two slices of pie - pepperoni and sausage.
The place is the TRUTH! Great price, authentic New York style and friendly serve... What are you waiting for, order something.
Store front
The NY Slice Pizza ·$$

Authentic New York Style Pizza Calzones/Stomboli Salads Cannoli

Website: thenyslice.com

Phone: (317) 887-1009

Open now

  • Wed 11:30 AM - 7:30 PM

1201 Greenwood Park East Dr Greenwood, IN 46142 ·376.15 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
4.0 126 reviews
5 star
70 4 star
14 3 star
16 2 star
9 1 star
17
Haley M. 10/04/26

Not only great pizza but great company. Owner was amazing and once inside, felt the authenticity of both Dan and the NY pie!

More
Mac C. 06/01/26

Wow! Don't let the outside fool you! I never stopped in because I judged and said how could the pizza be appetizing considering the building looks so rundown?? After reading many positive...

More
WInter K. 08/02/26

The food was amazing. This is a real taste of New York style pizza. We took 2 slices and garlic knots to go. The pizza was fresh, thin, crispy and sturdy. The seasoning he added took it over the...

More
Steven G. 09/04/26

Amazing pizza! Rough looking building but don't judge a book by its cover. Pizza is perfect

More
Cody K. 05/29/25

Finally gave this a try recently and was pleasantly surprised. My experience picking it up from the physical location was much better than my prior experiences with their food trucks; the food was...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: