Yahoo
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
El Mar, NY posters.
(L) white pie with spinach, (R) Margherita
Weighted down roast chicken, mozzarella and roasted red peppers
More za's!
Bacon, egg and cheddar on a plain bagel. $10.50  Delicious
Inside
ElMar's New York Pizza Pizza

Closed now

  • Fri 7:30 AM - 10:00 AM, 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

15725 37th Ave N Plymouth, MN 55446 ·873.68 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.5 299 reviews
5 star
219 4 star
44 3 star
16 2 star
8 1 star
12
Lily D. 10/20/26

So many big slices of fun options! The staff were so friendly when answering questions. They offer a punch card for a free slice after 10. They warmed up the slices, but it's not piping hot....

More
Max G. 08/27/26

Several people, including New Yorkers who moved to Minnesota, have told me this is the best NY Pizza in the state. With a crunchy New York slice being my favorite style of my favorite food, let's...

More
Jeff L. 07/25/26

ElMar's Pizza may be a small neighborhood spot, but it's serving some legitimately good New York-style pizza--something that's surprisingly hard to find around here. Get there early if you want...

More
Mark T. 10/27/26

Brooklyn style pizza sold by the slice or whole pie. Nice outdoor patio and comfy indoor seating as well. Soda pop is refillable (I assume since your fill your own anyway) I've been a handful of...

More
Holly N. 10/15/26

Phenomenal! That's it, that's all. Best pizza in town. Crust is thin and crispy in all the right places. Love the ricotta option as cheese - it's literally life changing. You can half them, whole...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: