Elsie Mae's offers jams, preserves, and drink mixes, as well as traditional and specialty pies. All canning and baking takes place in store using all natural, local ingredients from local farms whenever possible. Many different varieties of pot pies offered (you bake). Also offered is Rushing Waters salmon and fish products. Call before you visit, not all days have pies stocked for sale.
Website: elsiemaescanningandpies.com
Phone: (262) 914-9198
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of E Brady St and N Humboldt Ave
Closed now
- Wed Closed
1101 E Brady St Milwaukee, WI 53202 ·564.68 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Accessible
Reviews
yelpI can only comment on the pie itself and not service since I purchased a Elsie Mae's cherry mini pie at Swans pumpkin farm for my son who let mom have a few bites :) I have never heard of Elsie...
MoreWhile in concept the company is nice, in actuality it is a company that is not responsive to experiences that individuals have encountered. I was there last weekend with family and the one...
MoreWe bought some mini pies from Elsie Mae's at the Naperville farmers market (surprised they come all the way down from Kenosha!) They were already sold out of a few of their varieties by the time...
MoreVentured to the business park location in Lake Mills to check out Elsie Mae's. What a pleasant surprise ... the turnovers and mini pies are delicious! I'll be back!
MoreThe pies may be good but do not trust them for pre-orders. They made a big deal about a Mother's Day promotion with pickups at local farmers markets and despite happily taking our money, they had...
More