Yahoo
Chocolate Blackout
Vietnamese coffee
2025 (melted butter not their fault lol)
Matcha Bubble Tea & Taro Ice Cream
@eatingsfrom - earl gray flotea
$14.75 - I Dream of Taro Ice Cream Cake jar
Mozzarella!!!!!
Earl Grey Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Ice Cream
Surreal Creamery Ice Cream & Yogurt ·$$

Indulge in our Custom Cake and Ice Cream Jars, Floteas, Bubble Teas, and Hot Chocolates!

Website: surrealcreamery.com

Phone: (646) 355-8577

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of MacDougal St and Minetta Ln

Closed now

  • Mon 2:00 PM - 11:00 PM

126 MacDougal St New York, NY 10012 ·347.52 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 225 reviews
5 star
119 4 star
61 3 star
29 2 star
6 1 star
10
Ally L. 08/10/25

Cute ice cream shop near WSP ~ Everyone's always super friendly and will explain the menu to you and the different combos. Flavors are good, light, different mix and match vibes ~ Def a SHARED...

More
Tamara B. 07/26/25

I was really craving ice cream and stumbled across Surreal Ice Cream on Instagram!! the purple and green swirl immediately caught my eye (usually a sign of matcha and ube or taro, which I love)....

More
Farrah B. 12/31/25

The staff here is top tier. From making unique desserts, having exclusive events to bringing characters to life. The store is small, but the flavors are big, ive got to try the Thai iced tea ice...

More
Ayana A. 11/12/25

Visited for a post birthday treat for friend! I love their ice cream flavors and you get a good amount of ice cream for a great price. All of these were the smallest size cup for around $9, and...

More
Gab G. 09/04/24

First time at this location. I got a taro and matcha swirl in a cup with mochi bites, waffle cookie and stroopwaffle. It was really good, and I would be giving this place 5 stars except that it...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: