Yahoo
Emily Burger
Le Big Matt
The Emmy
Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens Pizza ·$$

Emily and Matt Hyland opened their first restaurant, Emily, in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, in 2014 with a simple goal: to create chef-inspired pies topped with ingredients they genuinely loved. A trip to visit friends in Detroit changed everything. They fell in love with the local pizza style, known for its crispy cheese edges, airy dough, and bold red sauce. Matt recognized that pairing this incredible foundation with chef-inspired toppings could create something truly special. Back in the basement of their Brooklyn shop, Matt began experimenting with organic flour, aged cheeses, fresh tomatoes, and countless topping combinations. From truffle and mushrooms to jalapeño and pepperoni, and pesto with Calabrian chilies, each pizza maintained the signature cheese-crusted edge that makes Detroit-style pizza so craveable. In 2016, after countless rounds of testing (and tasting), Emily and Matt introduced their take on Detroit-style pizza with the opening of Emmy Squared Pizza. Since then, Matt has continued to develop new toppings and recipes, remaining committed to crafting some of the most thoughtful and distinctive pizzas in the country. They hope you enjoy them as much as they do. Brooklyn Born, Detroit-Style Soul. An Empire State of Mind, a Motor City Plate of Pizza.

Website: emmysquaredpizza.com

Phone: (762) 315-4005

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Prince Ave and N Newton St

Open now

  • Sat 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

199 Prince Ave Athens, GA 30601 ·355.61 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.5 132 reviews
5 star
94 4 star
11 3 star
8 2 star
7 1 star
12
Thomas P. 10/20/26

My wife and I absolutely loved Emmy Squared Pizza. The gluten-free crust was EPIC! We have never found a gluten-free pizza crust this thick, fluffy, and full of flavor. Seriously, it was amazing....

More
Charlotte V. 08/14/26

Some important details. The food is really great, and if you're coming for the food, I highly recommend this place. The service, however, isn't great. It seems like a lot of college students...

More
Mike H. 08/13/26

I had never heard of Emmy's until we stumbled upon it on and I am glad we did. Apparently, Emmy's is a chain, but a good chain serving mainly Detroit style pizza in a more fru-fru...

More
Niya B. 03/10/26

The good: The angel pizza was truly angelic. It looked like the photo online and tasted better than I predicted. I would definitely order that again. Another huge hit was the shaved brussel sprout...

More
Doug F. 08/24/26

Excellent pizza great salads Full bar they take reservations. I recommend a reservation on the weekend.

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: