Yahoo
Honey Earl grey custard pie
PB&J Poptart, Banana Stranger slice, Dirt Pie slice
Chocolate cherry hand pies
Orange tiramisu pie
Butterfinger, Swiss roll and banana pie
Banana pie, m&ms sprinkle cookie, pumpkin thai tea pop tart
Pastries and cookies
Oatmeal cream pie and waffle maple blueberry pie
Pie Slayer Desserts

Website: eatpieslayer.com

Phone: (910) 380-6842

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Princess St and 2nd St

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Tue Closed

129 Princess St Wilmington, NC 28401 ·273.87 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.5 24 reviews
5 star
17 4 star
5 3 star
1 2 star
1 1 star
0
Lisa D. 05/17/26

Tried the lemon pie with ritz crust and apple hand pie. We would repeat on our next trip. This is an evening bakery opens at 3 and didn't disappoint:)

More
Marie P. 09/27/26

The banana stranger cookie was one of the best I've ever had. It tasted like a cross between a chocolate chip cookie and banana bread. It was a great consistency and I wish I lived there so I...

More
VJ W. 12/21/25

I want so badly to love Pie Slayer, but every time I feel like I overpaid for an average slice of pie. I do feel like they use quality ingredients and make everything by hand, but I've never had a...

More
Sydney H. 11/16/25

Stopped here after dinner and there was so many great dessert options! It was so hard to choose!! The person working behind the counter was so nice! We really enjoyed all the things we got. There...

More
Sara R. 10/12/26

Products are always picture perfect, and even more delicious than they are photogenic! The bakers are super responsive and helpful. this business is an amazing addition to downtown Wilmington! if...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: