Yahoo
Roni and Hawaiian
12/20/2023  BBQ Chicken and Sicilian slice.
12/20/2023 Garlic bread sticks, with the option of cheese and comes with tomato sauce. Quick tasty.
Benny's Pizza Pizza
Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Fri 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

18 West Rd Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 ·395.42 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 13 reviews
5 star
8 4 star
1 3 star
1 2 star
1 1 star
2
Ernie F. 12/30/23

As there are many pizza places to check out, this is another one. Benny's is still new on the block, and progress is being made. The selections and toppings are endless with the pizza -- so far,...

More
Nicholas S. 10/23/26

Where did Bella's go...Just ordered from here, wholeheartedly wanted to give it another shot But again, very disappointed, this is officially the last time I'm ordering here. Wings were not...

More
A T. 10/18/25

Amazing pizza and salad. The grandma pizza is our favorite but everything is delicious. Benny had catered a party we attended so we already knew the food was amazing. They delivered as promised...

More
Scotty W. 08/16/25

Tried Benny's Pizza and stromboli, for the first time and the last time. Pizza slice was larger than most other pizzeria's but sauce and cheese had zero flavor. The stromboli or should I say...

More
P V. 10/22/24

Stopped by randomly. Absolutely killer slices, I'll be honest the plaza and place look disappointing from the outside but once you walk in the place is spotless clean and their specialty slices...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: