I don’t think it is worth the price! $10.99 for one slice of turkey! Not even a big slice! Not worth it! Never going back again.

This is one of the newest and best offerings in Middlebury. Probably one of the best barbecue spots in the region, also a coffee place, pretzels, candy. A previous review stated no ice cream.. this has changed! There is now an ice cream parlor as well. Highly recommended.

Generous 3 stars here.Unique location in an old creamery building hence the name. Possibly Amish owned as all employees seen were wearing traditional Amish attire. Burning cherry and maple here. Smallish menu with the usual meat choices. NO website menu presence. All meats and sides sold separately, even on a meat combo plate. Word of advice-there is a menu board high above the order counter and a paper menu available. To be fully informed about the menu items, be ready to ask questions or READ the paper menu. The board does not provide the full details. Two meat platter seemed quite inexpensive at $16. With separate side of what is called Smoked Mac & Cheese plus an order of cornbread. Once our order was ready for pickup I discovered-after not reading the paper menu-that the mac and cheese was called smoked because it is topped with pulled pork and BBQ sauce. This is truly not made known by reading the menu board. As my DW does not enjoy pulled pork I asked to change to a portion without it. When we started to eat this, it tasted no different than any other commercially produced item you can get anywhere. The low price for the meats-baby backs and turkey-became more clear upon pickup. The portions could only be described as tiny. Three bones (quarter rack) from the thin end of a rack no bigger than a deck of cards with bones about the size of my stubby fingers. And ONE half sized slice (see photo) of turkey about the size of a slice of cheese. As a one person meal it was probably ok but we are used to sharing a two meat platter in other areas that is much easier to feed two people. The ribs were very flavorful if just a touch overcooked-no pull just fell apart. The turkey would only be described as fine but without any discernible smoke flavor. From all we could see there was only one sauce choice which was quite sweet to our taste. Did not try with the turkey and was good on the ribs. Cornbread was again a small piece and had good flavor but was very crumbly to the touch and fell totally apart if you tried to add any butter. No dessert today though the carrot cake looked good.

Simply the best! Who knew you needed Carmel sauce for your French fries! Such a delicious, unexpected surprise. We visited twice on our trip just for the Carmel sauce. Plus the barbecue was fantastic. We got the pulled pork and the meat was nice and moist. Topped with their own sauce to compliment the meat. Perfect! We can’t wait to visit again!

Called creamery because of the history of the building. There is no cheese or ice cream here.There are 4 businesses and each have their own hours. It's like a warehouse that has been subdivided.It is next to pumpkin vine bike/walk path