Yahoo
Small cup ($6)
Assorted flavors
Jelly donut custard
Menu as of September 2025
Muller's Creamery Ice Cream & Yogurt

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Main St and Robbins St

Open now

  • Fri 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

53 Main St Toms River, NJ 08753 ·313.36 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.5 9 reviews
5 star
7 4 star
1 3 star
1 2 star
0 1 star
0
Dayton L. 06/07/26

Whelp ...we've evolved to taking Muller's custard ice cream home and keeping some on hand in our freezer. How cool is that! Pun intended.

More
David Y. 09/08/25

Came here on a Friday night with my family after dinner. The place is inside of a building, easy to find and you will know what I mean when you get there. I got a small cup ($6) which comes in...

More
Victor S. 08/18/26

All ice cream made from scratch! Owner's super friendly. Lemon lavender is so good! Definitely plan to come back!

More
Dave D. 04/13/24

We discovered them during Toms River Street festivals and not only loved the ice cream but enjoyed the customer service especially the interactions with our grandson! So you can just imagine...

More
Jean E. 10/10/25

Such welcoming owners, delicious flavors and a variety of selections at a sweet location. We visited from out of town, taking a chance from an online review, that proved to be an enjoyable...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: