Yahoo
Indoor dining
More Than Pudding - Shop Interior
More Than Pudding - Shop Interior
Dessert bar
More Than Pudding Desserts

Do you love decadent puddings and treat? Come by More Than Pudding and try our unique frozen custard style puddings, warm bread puddings, creamy rice puddings, jumbo cookies and the TikTok famous “Crookie” (warm, fresh croissant with a cookie baked inside and on top!)

Website: morethanpudding.com

Phone: (850) 825-1801

Interested in our services?

Open now

  • Fri 12:00 PM - 12:00 AM

3020 W Pensacola St Tallahassee, FL 32304 ·592.79 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible

Reviews

yelp
4.5 11 reviews
5 star
8 4 star
1 3 star
0 2 star
1 1 star
1
Allie C. 06/23/26

I visited more than pudding a few days ago, and WOW! Great service the woman helping me out was very nice. I got the Cinnabon bread pudding, which was absolutely delicious. I also got the cookie...

More
Myesha S. 10/01/25

This was a nice treat! They have puddings, custards, banana breads, and cookies. I opted for a chunky monkey banana pudding custard which was delicious and had biscotti biscuit pieces and it was...

More
Cory B. 05/14/25

Cute new place in town! Service was quick and staff was willing to converse with us. We didn't get any baked goods but the puddings were delicious. The puddings are chilled and creamy, which I...

More
Diane H. 05/21/25

More Than Pudding Dessert Shop opened in December 2024. I thought it was a novel concept, and after a recent dessert sampling event at Tallahassee State College, my dining companion, and I decided...

More
Chloe B. 01/18/25

This a a first impression review. Walking into the establishment, we were warmly welcomed by who was later identified as the owner. The customer service of her and her employee was very pleasant....

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: